Skip to main content

Amandi Law

What Happens at a Bail Hearing in Ontario

Light through a barred cell window, with the Amandi Law logo

A bail hearing decides whether a person charged with a crime can go home while the case moves forward, or must stay in custody. In most cases, police who keep someone in custody must bring them before a justice within 24 hours. Stricter federal bail rules took effect on July 15, 2026, so the plan you bring to court now carries more weight.

The short version

  • In most cases, the Crown must show why you should stay in custody. For some charges, you must show why you should be released.
  • More charges now carry that reverse burden, and the court looks harder at your bail plan.
  • A surety is a person who promises the court to supervise you and can lose money if you break the rules.
  • Breaking a bail condition can lead to a new arrest and a new charge.

Who decides, and how fast it happens

Not everyone who is charged goes to bail court. Police can release you with an appearance notice or an undertaking, which tells you when to come to court.

If police keep you, the Criminal Code sets the 24-hour limit for cases where a justice is available. When none is, you must be brought before one as soon as possible.

At bail court, a judge or a justice of the peace hears the case. The Crown prosecutor either agrees to your release or asks the court to hold you. When the Crown opposes release, both sides make their arguments and the court rules. Cases that need more time than a regular bail court day are set down as special bail hearings.

The test the court uses

Under section 515 of the Criminal Code, you have the right to be released unless the Crown proves that jail is justified. The court can only hold you on one or more of three grounds:

  1. Primary ground: custody is needed to make sure you come to court.
  2. Secondary ground: custody is needed for public safety.
  3. Tertiary ground: releasing you would undermine public confidence in the justice system.

For some charges the burden flips. Lawyers call this a reverse onus. It means you, usually through your lawyer, must prove that holding you is not justified on any of the three grounds.

What the new federal law changed

The Bail and Sentencing Reform Act (Bill C-14) is the law behind the stricter rules. It made bail harder to get for violent and repeat offences. A reverse onus now applies to:

  • auto theft that is violent or linked to organized crime
  • break and enter of a home
  • trafficking in persons and human smuggling
  • assault or sexual assault that involves choking, suffocating or strangling
  • extortion involving violence
  • serious violent offences where the person has two or more past convictions for similar offences

For weapon-related violence, the court now looks back 10 years for prior convictions instead of five. Judges must also weigh whether the alleged violence was random or unprovoked, and whether the person already faces many or serious charges. Police must hold a person for a bail hearing when that is needed to protect the public, including victims and witnesses.

In every reverse onus case, the court no longer starts from the least strict form of release. You must clearly show that your bail plan deals with the risks of letting you out.

Building a bail plan

A bail plan answers the court’s worries about letting you go. Legal Aid Ontario says a plan usually covers:

  1. where you will live
  2. who will supervise you
  3. the conditions you can follow
  4. your work or school
  5. how you will deal with any drug or alcohol problems
  6. how you will keep track of court dates and get there

Give your lawyer the names and phone numbers of family or friends who can help. Also mention any injury, illness, mental health or addiction needs, and whether you identify as First Nation, Métis or Inuit. These details can change what the plan looks like.

What a surety does

A surety is someone who agrees to be responsible for you until your case ends. They make sure you attend court and obey your conditions. Every surety takes on a money obligation, usually a promise to pay a set amount if things go wrong. A surety who cannot pay may be ordered to serve time in jail.

Your lawyer may call the surety as a witness, and the Crown can question them about how they will supervise you. A surety can also go to the courthouse at any time and ask to be released from the role. Under the new law, someone convicted of a serious offence within the past 10 years cannot be a surety unless no other suitable person is available.

If someone you love is waiting for a bail hearing, it helps to have a lawyer shape the plan before court, and we accept Legal Aid certificates for criminal matters. See how we help with criminal charges.

Release orders, conditions and breaches

When the court lets you go, it issues a release order. In a regular case, the court follows the ladder principle. It starts at the bottom and only climbs when a lower step will not work:

  1. release with no conditions
  2. release with conditions but no money owed
  3. a promise to pay a set amount if you break the order
  4. release to one or more sureties
  5. a deposit of money, which can also be required if you live outside Ontario or more than 200 km from where you are held

Common conditions include no contact with the alleged victim or witnesses, living at a set address, staying inside a set area and having no weapons.

Treat every condition as a court order, because it is one. If you break a condition or miss court, police can arrest you and hold you. You can face new charges for failing to comply or failing to appear, and you or your surety may have to pay the amount promised.

After you are released

Your next court date is in case management court, and the date and place appear on your release order. We explain what happens there, and how to get the Crown’s evidence, in What Happens at Your First Court Appearance in Ontario.

Questions people ask

Can I get a free lawyer at a bail hearing in Ontario?

Yes. Legal Aid Ontario has free lawyers called duty counsel in bail court every day. They can speak for you that day if you do not have your own lawyer. You can also hire a lawyer, and Amandi Law accepts Legal Aid certificates for criminal cases.

What if no one can be my surety?

Legal Aid Ontario says a Bail Supervision Program may be an option when no family member or friend can take on the role. Ask duty counsel or your lawyer whether it fits your situation.

Can my bail conditions be changed later?

Yes. If the Crown agrees, both sides complete a consent variation form, and the change takes effect only once a judicial official signs off. If the Crown does not agree, you can apply to the Superior Court of Justice under section 520 of the Criminal Code. Until a change is approved, your current conditions still apply.

Need advice on your situation?

Every case is different. Talk it through with us.

Get in touch

Send us an inquiry

Have a question about your own situation? Tell us a little about it. Your inquiry goes straight to our office and we will be in touch.

Call647 741 7931

Emailtawfic@amandilaw.com

Visit1315 Finch Ave. W, Suite 400
Toronto (North York), ON M3J 2G6

HoursMonday to Friday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Book onlineBook a free assessment

Keep reading

More insights